The matter of aesthetics: Why our tastes deserve serious attention

By:
Joy Pope

This story is part of Humanities in Practice, a Franklin College of Arts and Sciences series exploring the value of the humanities in work and everyday life.

When people argue about whether a movie is brilliant or overrated, they do more than express a preference. They offer reasons, apply standards, and sometimes persuade someone to see the work differently.

In other words, they are practicing philosophy.

Aaron Meskin, professor and head of philosophy in the University of Georgia’s Franklin College of Arts and Sciences, studies aesthetics, the branch of philosophy concerned with art and our responses to it. His research addresses questions people encounter regularly. What makes art good? Can a popular work also be artistically serious? When people disagree about taste, can anyone be right?

“The aesthetic domain—the arts, beauty, creativity and so on—is a central part of what makes life meaningful for many, perhaps most, people,” Meskin said.

Aesthetics encourages people to examine their responses and explain the judgments behind them. For Meskin, saying “I like it, but I know it’s not that good” makes sense. People routinely debate the merits of movies and novels. They make judgments about buildings, clothing, and food. In doing so, they may point out an overlooked feature or question the standards someone else is using.

Those standards depend partly on context. Meskin compares aesthetic judgment to judgments about height. A person who stands 6 feet 6 inches would be tall in most settings, but the standard changes on a professional basketball court.

Artistic judgments can work similarly. People may assess a work according to its purpose or the tradition to which it belongs. Audience expectations can also shape the judgment. The study of aesthetics helps uncover these standards and explain why a work succeeds—or why it matters to us.

Meskin applies this approach to categories that people often accept without examining. In 2025, he and University of Arizona philosopher Jonathan M. Weinberg published “Middlebrow Aesthetics: An Explanation and Defense” in “Pacific Philosophical Quarterly.”

Their essay reconsiders “middlebrow” art, a term often used as an insult. Meskin and Weinberg define it as work that seeks a broad audience while pursuing ambitions associated with high art. Those ambitions might include thematic depth or philosophical seriousness.

Blockbuster filmmaker Christopher Nolan is an almost quintessential example.

“He’s going to make a popular movie,” Meskin said, “but he’s going to aim at something thematically important.”

John Updike’s Rabbit novels offer another example, as does Woody Allen’s Crimes and Misdemeanors. Meskin and Weinberg use the category to describe a work’s aims rather than determine its quality.

Their argument challenges a longstanding cultural hierarchy. Virginia Woolf famously despised the middlebrow. Other critics have also treated popular appeal as incompatible with artistic seriousness.

“People think of ‘middlebrow’ as a slur,” Meskin said. “Our whole point is that middlebrow can be valuable.”

A middlebrow work can succeed or fail, but Meskin and Weinberg argue that the effort to combine accessibility with artistic ambition has value. Such works can bring complex ideas to broad audiences. Studying them also encourages people to question the assumptions behind labels such as “serious” or “popular.” That process is at the heart of humanistic inquiry.

The subjects considered worthy of philosophical attention have also expanded. Philosophers of art once concentrated primarily on established forms such as classical music, literature, and painting. Today, they also study street art and comics. Video games, tattoos, and other parts of contemporary life have become subjects of philosophical inquiry as well.

Meskin’s interests include places people value for reasons that extend beyond their commercial purpose. He has studied record shops and has begun considering the aesthetics of bars.

A dive bar comes with expectations, Meskin said. Elaborate décor or fancy ferns might feel wrong. Its character may come from the people who frequent it or from its welcoming atmosphere. Even the freedom to move chairs together can help create its appeal.

Record stores raise related questions. Their role as retail businesses cannot fully explain why people linger in them or mourn their disappearance. The possibility of discovery contributes to their aesthetic value, as do atmosphere and a sense of community.

Even authenticity changes across settings. An authentic Picasso raises different philosophical questions from an authentic Oaxacan mole. A song that seems to express its performer authentically raises still others. With some works, Meskin said, audiences seek “an honest expression of an artist’s personality.”

Philosophy can illuminate experiences that are easy to dismiss as merely subjective or ordinary. It gives students ways to examine inherited categories and articulate their own judgments. It can also help them understand why someone else sees things differently.

“Taking our aesthetic interests in rock and roll, tattoos, and dive bars seriously,” Meskin said, “means we take ourselves seriously.”

The Franklin College of Arts and Sciences’ 1801 Lecture Series explores connections between science and the humanities through the joy of curiosity. The series launched Sept. 8 with science communicator and “Ologies” host Alie Ward. The lecture series and Franklin’s forthcoming Applied Humanities Certificate are supported by the Teagle Foundation’s Cornerstone: Learning for Living initiative.

 

Featured in News View (i.e. Ethics and Academic Innovation Articles pages):